Sunlight that gets through the snow can melt it from underneath, even on a cloudy day below freezing, so a metal roof can drop its whole load at once. Snow guards brace the bottom of the snowpack so it leaves gradually. The Metal Construction Association's guidance is to plan where sliding snow will land and, once a roof gets guards, to cover the building's full eave line rather than one spot. Standing seam takes clamps on the seams, with no holes; Tuff Rib takes guards fastened through the panel. The association advises against glue-on guards and plastic parts.
Part of the appeal of a metal roof is that it won’t hang on to snow. The snow slides off instead of weighing on the rafters all winter. (Our metal roof vs. shingles comparison covers metal’s other pros and cons.) What surprises people is how it leaves: the whole load on a slope can come off in a single slab, onto whatever sits below the eave.
There’s plenty to shed here. Davis County’s climate page puts the average winter at roughly 60 inches of snow on the valley floor and up to 90 inches on the high bench areas. Snow guards keep that snow up top until it can melt away gradually. This article explains why the snow slides, where guards belong, and how they’re fixed to standing seam and Tuff Rib roofs.
Why metal sheds its snow in one slab
Snow that lands on a cold metal roof bonds to the panels. The Metal Construction Association (MCA), an industry group for metal construction, explains what breaks that bond in its bulletin on metal roof design for cold climates. Some sunlight passes through the snow and warms the panel, so the snowpack melts from underneath, even on cloudy days with the air well below freezing. Once the panel warms, that bond breaks and meltwater all but removes the friction, so the entire accumulation can release at once.
The MCA’s companion bulletin on snow retention says a roof can unload tons of snow onto whatever is under its eaves in a matter of seconds, from people and cars to landscaping and parts of the building. It calls snow retention a life-safety matter.
FEMA’s Snow Load Safety Guide adds two points:
- A gentle pitch doesn’t rule it out. FEMA classes metal panels as slippery and says snow has been observed sliding at pitches down to 10 degrees, just over 2 in 12. Steeper roofs shed more readily.
- Lower roofs catch what falls. FEMA’s common examples are porch roofs, sunroom roofs and entry canopies under a higher roof. The snow piles deeper where the slide lands, an uneven load, and FEMA warns that the force of the slide hitting a lower roof can potentially overload its framing.
How a few inches of metal hold back feet of snow
Snow guards work at the base of the snowpack. The MCA explains that a snowbank’s bottom layers are its densest and strongest, so a device a few inches high can brace a bank many feet deep. Held in place, the snow leaves gradually, melting or turning straight to vapor, instead of coming down in one drop.
The MCA describes two families:
- Rail systems, or snow fence: brackets or seam clamps fixed to the roof, carrying cross-members that run sideways across the slope.
- Cleats, or pads: small separate units near the eave, sometimes repeated farther up the slope, that rely on the snow to span the gaps between them.
Both have performed satisfactorily when the design and installation are done right, the cold-climate bulletin says. The snow retention bulletin adds that snowpack varies too much for any guard to promise to stop every slide. A properly designed system greatly lowers the risk of a rooftop avalanche; it doesn’t remove it.
Shed or hold: start with where the snow lands
Holding snow isn’t the only option. The MCA’s cold-climate bulletin considers it appropriate, where possible, to let snow slide freely off a low-rise building, as long as the design allows for it: entrances under gable ends instead of eaves, foot traffic and parking routed away from the drop zones, and anything permanent in the snow’s path built to take the impact. Where a building can’t be arranged that way, it points to snow retention.
So take a lap around the house and note what’s under each metal eave:
- An entry door, a walkway or the driveway
- A place where cars park
- A deck or patio
- A porch, sunroom or other lower roof
- An air conditioner or other equipment
- Shrubs or garden beds you’d like to keep
If a slide would hit any of those, the bulletin’s choices are to move it, build it to take the hit, or keep the snow on the roof. Snow that drops onto open ground nobody uses in winter may be fine to let go.
Placing the guards
Cover the eave line, not one spot
Once a roof is getting snow guards, the MCA’s snow retention bulletin gives a general guideline: protect the entire eave line of the building rather than an isolated area, because the force on a short section of guards on a large roof is very difficult to estimate accurately. The cold-climate bulletin explains part of the reason. Snow held behind an isolated run of guards builds up as a wedge, not a rectangle, so it can draw on a much larger area than it first appears. Our metal roof vs. shingles comparison passes along the same guideline. With the eave line covered, shorter sections can go farther up the roof, above things like a flue, for extra protection.
Keep the first row near the edge
The cold-climate bulletin puts the first row within 12 inches of where the panels end at the eave. When retained snow finally gives way, it tends to shear off near the guard, and whatever is below that line can drop, so a row near the edge keeps that piece small. That’s the MCA’s guideline. Its snow retention bulletin also says placement should be specified by the system’s designer, so the exact rows come from the layout for that roof and that product.
When one row isn’t enough
The number of rows comes from a calculation: the snow’s push on each panel against what each guard can hold (the next section shows the size of that push). Extra rows usually go in the bottom half of the slope, the cold-climate bulletin says. For especially critical spots, it notes, a second row is sometimes added even when the math says one will do, because a thin layer of wet new snow, particularly on a steep roof, can on rare occasions buckle and fold over a single row.
Heat cable at the eave
With heat cable along the eave, the cold-climate bulletin moves the first row to just upslope of the cable, in place of the 12-inch rule. It says snow retention is needed there so moving snow doesn’t tear surface-mounted cable off the roof. (Our ice dam article explains what heat tape can and can’t do.)
The weight behind the guards
Utah’s building code for homes lists ground snow loads for selected cities. Farmington’s is 35 pounds per square foot at an elevation of 4,318 feet; where elevation varies a lot within a town, the load applies at and below that elevation. For other locations in Utah, the code refers to Utah State University’s Utah Snow Load Study. Heber City, across the mountains, is listed at 60. The table notes that it leaves out local building authorities’ own requirements, so check with your city’s building department too.
A roof’s design snow load isn’t the ground figure: the MCA notes that codes adjust it for things like wind and roof temperature. A guard resists the snow’s pull down the slope, which grows with that roof load, the pitch and the distance from eave to ridge. On metal, the MCA’s snow retention bulletin normally assumes no friction to help.
The cold-climate bulletin’s worked example shows the scale. A roof that runs 35 feet in plan from eave to ridge, at a 7-in-12 pitch with a design roof snow load of 58 pounds per square foot, puts about 1,023 pounds of downslope force on every foot of eave. That 58 is a roof design load, well above the 35-pound ground load the code lists for Farmington, so 1,023 isn’t a Davis County figure or your roof’s. It’s why the MCA wants snow retention engineered for each roof surface, with the calculation method in its cold-climate bulletin or by a licensed design professional, rather than guessed at.
Standing seam: the clamp grips the seam
Standing seam panels grow and shrink with the temperature, and the clips holding them down let them slide. A guard screwed through the panel would lock it in place, so the MCA says screw-through devices generally shouldn’t go on standing seam unless they’re proven to leave the panel free to move along its length. Instead, guards mount with seam clamps that squeeze the raised seam with set screws, leaving the panel unpunctured. Two details from the MCA:
- The clamp has to suit the seam. Standing seam comes in many profiles, metals and gauges, and test results for one profile, maker, metal or gauge can’t be swapped in for another.
- The screw tips matter. Some clamps use cup-point set screws that can tear the seam or damage its coating under load; others use round-tipped screws to avoid that. The snow retention bulletin’s definition of a seam clamp calls for rounded-point set screws.
Tuff Rib and other screw-down panels
Tuff Rib is fastened through the face with screws that carry rubber sealing washers. Since that kind of roof already has many penetrations, the MCA’s cold-climate bulletin says a few more are consistent with its design, and the snow retention bulletin says guards should be mechanically attached through the panels into the deck or framing underneath. Two things matter:
- What the screws go into. The MCA wants the calculations tied to the specific material under the panel, such as plywood or OSB decking, and backed by lab tests in it with the same fasteners.
- Staying watertight. Each added screw is another hole. The MCA calls for washers and sealants of the same chemistry and durability as those already in the roof, placed out of direct sun.
Glue-on guards and plastic parts
The MCA advises against two kinds of snow guard:
- Adhesive-only guards. The snow retention bulletin doesn’t recommend adhesive attachment for the main load-carrying parts on any type of metal roof. The cold-climate bulletin explains why: adhesive strength weakens with age and weather, some premium paint finishes have a fairly non-stick surface, and some adhesives need set conditions through a cure that can last as long as 28 days.
- Plastic. Plastic components haven’t proven they can stay in service for a roof’s expected life, the MCA says, so it limits them to secondary parts or leaves them out. For coated steel roofs it prefers structural-grade aluminum alloys or 300-series stainless steel.
Winter around a metal roof
- Treat the eaves as a drop zone. Sun can loosen the snow even on a cloudy day well below freezing, so a slide doesn’t need a warm spell. The cold-climate bulletin’s advice is to keep people and vehicles away from the eaves where you can.
- Leave the shovel on the ground. FEMA’s snow guide says that, more often than not, trying to clear snow off a roof does more harm than good, to the person and to the roof.
- Know the warning signs. FEMA’s signs of a roof straining under snow include sagging ceilings, popping or cracking noises, and doors or windows that no longer open or close. If you see them, it says to get everyone out promptly and call a qualified design professional, such as a professional engineer.
- Ice along the eave is its own problem. The MCA notes that ice bonded at the eave can hold the snow above it, then break loose when conditions change and release both at once. Our ice dam article covers why ice builds up and what stops it.
Common questions
Will keeping snow on the roof overload it?
The MCA’s snow retention bulletin says a building designed to current codes and standards is presumed to be engineered for its design roof snow load. The one exception is a roof designed with the reduced load the engineering standard allows for an unobstructed slippery roof, which counts on the snow sliding off. On that structure, snow retention is prohibited under the MCA’s bulletin. If you don’t know how your house was designed, FEMA’s snow guide says the design snow load can be found on the construction drawings, and if there are none, to have a licensed design professional determine the roof’s capacity before the snow season.
Is it too late for snow guards on my existing metal roof?
The attachment methods the MCA favors, seam clamps on standing seam and fasteners through the panel on screw-down roofs like Tuff Rib, both go on top of the finished roofing, so guards aren’t limited to new roofs. The same guidance applies as on a new roof: retention engineered for that roof surface, with the eave line protected rather than one spot.
Are snow guards required by code?
The MCA’s snow retention bulletin notes that building authorities in most alpine regions of Europe and Scandinavia require snow guards, but in North America that’s quite rare and comes from local code authorities, if at all. Your city’s building department is the place to ask.
The honest next step
If you’re weighing a metal roof, decide where its snow will go while the roof is still being planned. The MCA’s cold-climate bulletin warns that snow shedding nobody planned for can be inconvenient, destructive, or both.
Wondering how your current metal roof is holding up? A free roof inspection is the easy way to find out. We get on the roof, photograph everything, check the fasteners on a metal roof, walk you through it in plain language, and tell you honestly whether anything needs doing.
The inspection is free, and we photograph everything we find.
